مخالفات الرازي لأبي مسلم الأصفهاني في تفسيره الكبير– الجزء الأول من سورة البقرة نموذجاً - عرض ودراسة نقدية.
The Differences between Abu Muslim al-Asfahani and Fakhruddin al-Razi in Surah al-Baqarah of al-Tafsir al-Kabir: A Critical Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33102/jmqs.v15i2.192Keywords:
Quranic exegesis, Fakhr al-Din al-Razi, al-Tafsir al-Kabir, Abu Muslim al- Asfhani.Abstract
This research is aimed at exploring interpretation differences in Surah al-Baqarah between Abu Muslim al-Asfahani (d. 322AH/933CE) and Fakhr al-Din al-Razi’s (d. 606/1210) al-Tafsir al-Kabir. Through critical study to uncover the character of these differences, comparing their interpretations with other exegetes as well as correlating their thought with the Quranic exegesis and its sciences, this study demonstrates that a possible tarjih (choosing between existing opinions) can be inferred on this matter. This approach facilitates to address the character of these differences at establishing their arguments that were supported with valid evidences. Hence, the study employs inductive analytical evidence-based approach that traces the controversial issues between Abu Muslim al-Asfahani and al-Razi in the first juz’ (part) of Surat al-Baqarah until verse 115 in al-Tafsir al-Kabir. To summarize the article, al-Razi's opposition to the opinions of Abu Muslim essentially followed the principles of Quranic exegesis and its sciences in addition to the advocacy of majority of Muslim scholars.
References
Abed El Hamid Omar, & Ahmad Moukhtar, (2003). Moua’jam al Louga Al Arabiya Al Moua’sira. Alaem Al Kutoub.
Abed El Rahman, Al Brak (2008). Shareh’ Al A’qidaa Al Tahawiyah. bDar Al- Tadmuriya.
Abu Al Suoud, (n.d.). Irshadul Aqelul salim ila Mazaya Al Kitab Al Aziem, Beirut, Dar al Kitab Al Arabi.
Abu Hayan, (1999). Al Baher Al MouHit Fi Al Tafsir. Beirut: Dar Al Fikr.
Al Alousi, (1994). Rouh Al Maa’ni. Beirut: Dar Alkutoub Al- I’lmiya.
Al Baghawi, (1997). Maa’lem Al tanzil Fi tafsir Al Quran, Tiyaba Lil Nasher Wa eltwazi’h.
Al Bayhaqi, (1993). Ahkam Al Quran Lil Shafii’, Al Kahira, Maktabat Al Kanji.
Al Biydawi, (1997). Anwar Al Tanzil Wa Asrar Al Ta’wil Beirut: Dar Ihya’ Al turath Al Arabi.
Al Boukhari, (2001) Al Jami’ al Mousnad al Sahih al- Moukhtasar min Umour Rasoul Allah (pbuh) Wa-Sunanihi Wa-Ayamihi, Beirut, Dar Tawek El Najat Mousawara A’n al Soultaniya bitarkim Mohamad Fouad Abed El baki.
Al Dawoudi, (n.d.), Tabakat al Moufasirien. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Faraa, (1964) Maa’ni al Quran. Misr: Dar Al Mariya Lil Tae’lief.
Al Ghazali, (1998). Al Mankhoul Min Ta’liqat AL Usul. Beirut; Dar Al Fiqr Al Moua’sira.
Al Hakim, (1990. Al Mustadrak A’la Al Sahihayein, Beirut; Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Hamwi, (1993). Mou”jam Al Oudaba’. Beirut, Dar Al Gareb Al Islami.
Al Jawi, (1996). Mera’h Labied likashef Ma’na AL Quran AL Majid. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Jouwayni, (1997). Al Burhan Fi Usul al Fiqh. Beirut, Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Qurtubi, (n.d.). Al Jamie’ LiAhkam Al Quran. AL Qahira: Dar AlKutub AL Masriya.
Al Maraghi, (1946). Tafsir aL Maraghi, Misr: Sharikat Maktabat Mustafa AL Babi AL Halabi Wa Awladou’.
Al Nasafi, (1998). Madarek aL Tanzil wa Hakaik Al Ta’wiel. Beirut: Dar AL Kalim AL Tayieb.
Al Naysabouri, (1994). Iyjaz AL Bayan A”n Ma”ani AL Quran. Beirut: Dar AL Gareb AL Islami.
Al Raghib Al Asfahni, (1999). Tafsir Al Ragib Al Asfahani. Misr; Kouliyat Al Adab, Tanta.
Al Razi, (1999). Al Tafsir al Kabir = Mafatieh Al Gayeib. Beirut: Dar Ihya’ Al Turath Al Arabi
Al Sabouni, (1997). Safwat al Tafasir. Al Kahira: Darul Sabouni Lil Tiba’a’ Wal Nashir Wal Tawzi’.
Al Sadousi, (1997), Al Nasikh Wal Mansoukh. Beirut: Mouassasat Al Risalah.
Al Sama’ani, (1997). Qawatieh Al Adila Fi Al Usul. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Suyouti, (n.d.). Al Durr Al Manthour. Dar Al Fiqr.
Al Suyouti, (n.d.). Bougyat Al Woua’t Fi tabakat Al Lougawyein Wal Nouhat. Saida, al Maktaba Al Asriya.
Al Suyouti, (n.d.). Libab Al Noukoul Fi asbab Al Nuzoul. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Al Tabari, (1999) Jami’ Al Bayan Fi ta’wiel Ayyi Al Quran. Beirut: Mouassasat Al Risalah.
Al Tirmizi, (1975). Sunan Al Tirmizi. Sharikat Maktabat wa Matba’at Mustafa Al Babi Al Halabi.
Al Ukbari, (n.d.). Al Tibyan Fi I’rab Al Quran. Isaa Al Babi Al Halabi Wa Shouraka’
Al Zajaj, (1988). Maa’ni Al Quran Wa I’rabihi. Beirut: Alam AlKutoub.
Al Zamakhshari, (1986). Al Kashaf, An Haqaiq Wa Gawamid Al Tanzil. Beirut: Dar al Kitab Al Arabi.
Al Zarkashi, (1993). Al Baher Al Mouhiet Fi Usul AL Fiqh, Dar Al Katbi.
Al Zarkashi (1957). Al Burhan Fi Ulum El Quran. Dar Ihaya’ El Kutub Al Arabiya Issa IL Babi El Halabi Wa Shurakah.
Al Wahidi, (2009) Al Basit Fil Tfsir. KSA, Imadat AL Baheth AL Ilmi Jamia’t AL Imam Mohamad Bin Sooud AL Islamiya.
Al Wahidi, (1991). Asbab AL Nouzoul. Ad-Dammam, Dar AL Islah.
Al Wahidi, (1994). Al Wasit Fi Tafsir Al Kitab Al Aziz. Beirut: Dar EL Kalam.
Ibn Aby Hatem, (1998). Tafsir Al-Quran Al- A’zim, KSA, Maktabat Nizar Mustafa Al Baz
Ibn Al Jawzi, (2001) Zad Al Masir Fi I”lm Al Tafsir. Beirut: Dar Al Kitab Al arabi.
Ibn Ashour, (1984), At-Tahrir Wal Tanwir. Tunis: Ad-Dar Atounisyia lin Nasher.
Ibn Atiya, (2001). Al Mouharrar AL wajiz Fi Tafsir El Kitab Al A’ziz. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Ibn Fares, (1997) Maqayies Al-Iugaa, Dar Al Fiqr.
Ibn Hajar, (n.d.). Al Oujab Fi Bayan Al Asbab, Dar Ibn Al Jawzi.
Ibn Hiban )1988). Al Ihsan Fi Takrib Sahih Ibn Hiban, Beirut: Mouassasat Al Risalah.
Ibn al Arabi, (1992). Al Nasikh Wal Mansoukh Fil Quran Al Kareem, Maktabat al thakafa Al Diniya.
Ibn Kathir, (1999). Tafsir Al Quran Al Aazim, Dar Tiyba Lil Nashir Wal Tawzieh.
Ibn Khilikan (1994). Wafayat IL A’yan Wa AnBaa’ Abna’ IL Zaman. Beirut: Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Ibn Taymiya, (n.d.) Al Risala AL Madaniya Fi Tahkik al Majaz Wal Hakika Fi Sifaat Allah (SWT), Al Kahira, Matbaat Al Madani.
Mohamad Omar al Jawi (1996) Beirut, Dar Al Kutoub Al I’lmiya.
Muslim ibn al Hajaj, (n.d.) Sahih Muslim. Beirut: Dar Ihya’ Al Turath Al Arabi.
Rida, Mohamad Rashid (1990). Tafsir Al Quran Al Azim= Tafsir AL Manar, Misr: Al Haya’ Al a’maa Lil Kitab.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2019 Ahmed Abdol Kareem El- Kubesi, Mona Mustafa Shehade Mustafa Shehade
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The copyright of this article will be vested to author(s) and granted the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, unless otherwise stated.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
